Choosing donor stewardship reporting software
Universities produce donor reports in four main ways: design tools (InDesign, Canva), Word mail merge from spreadsheets, reports built in the CRM, or a dedicated reporting platform. The right choice depends on volume, how personalized each report needs to be, and how many offices supply the data.
The four approaches at a glance
Each approach fits a different volume and level of personalization. This table summarizes the trade-offs; the sections below explain each one.
| Approach | Best for | Main strength | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Design tools (InDesign, Canva) | A small number of high-touch reports | Full creative control | Every report is built by hand |
| Word mail merge | Letter-style reports from one spreadsheet | Familiar, low setup | Hard to handle multiple funds, photos and charts |
| Your CRM (e.g. Raiser’s Edge, Salesforce) | Acknowledgments and simple statements | Donor and gift data already there | Stories, recipients and finance data live elsewhere |
| Dedicated reporting platform | Personalized reports at volume | Combines data and builds every report | Setup time and a new system to adopt |
Design tools: InDesign and Canva
Design tools produce the best-looking one-off reports. A skilled designer in InDesign, or a staff member in Canva, can build exactly what you picture, with full control over layout, photography and type.
The trade-off is that every report is assembled individually. Someone exports donor and fund data, collects stories, places each one, adds the right financials, and proofs the result. That works for a few dozen leadership donors. At hundreds of donors and funds, the time grows with every report, and a late change (a corrected fund balance, a student who withdraws) means reopening files. Reporting also depends on one or two people with design skills, which becomes a bottleneck when they are busy or leave.
InDesign’s data merge and Canva’s bulk create features help with simple, single-page variations. They don’t handle donors with several funds, funds with several donors, or pages that should appear only in some reports. For a detailed comparison, see Awarded vs. InDesign for donor reporting.
Word mail merge from spreadsheets
Mail merge is the most common starting point. It’s familiar, it costs nothing extra, and it works well for letter-style reports: a personalized letter with the fund name, the year’s distribution and a recipient’s name.
It breaks down as reports get richer. Mail merge expects one row per letter, so a donor with three funds or a fund with five recipients needs workarounds. Photos, charts and multi-page layouts are fragile. The data behind the merge is usually a spreadsheet stitched together by hand from several offices, and errors in that spreadsheet go straight into donors’ hands.
Reports built in your CRM
Your CRM is where donor and gift data already live, which makes it a natural place to start. CRMs such as Raiser’s Edge or Salesforce handle acknowledgment letters, giving summaries and simple fund statements well, and many institutions use them for exactly that.
The limit is the data that isn’t in the CRM. Recipient lists usually sit in financial aid or the SIS. Fund financials (market value, distributions, spendable amount) come from finance, often under different fund codes. Student thank-you notes and faculty updates are collected somewhere else again. Bringing that data into the CRM, and then producing a designed, multi-page report from it, usually takes custom work or a separate design step. For institutions whose reports are mostly letters, the CRM may be all they need.
Dedicated reporting platforms
A dedicated donor reporting platform is built for one job: combining donor, fund, financial and recipient data and producing a personalized report for every donor. Good platforms also collect stories from students and fund managers, handle the many-to-many relationships between donors, funds and recipients, and deliver reports in several formats.
The trade-offs are real. A platform needs setup: templates, data mapping and agreement between offices on fund codes and timelines. It’s another system for the team to learn. It makes the most sense when volume is high, when reports need financials and impact together, or when several offices supply the data.
An evaluation checklist
Use these questions to compare approaches or vendors. The right answers depend on your donor base and how your reports are structured today.
| Question | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Can each donor get one report across all their funds, or one per fund? | Donors with several funds shouldn’t get several disconnected mailings. |
| Does it handle funds with several donors and several recipients? | Most real fund data is many-to-many. |
| Can it include endowed fund statements from finance, by fund code? | Market value, book value, distributions and spendable amount have to match the books. |
| Does it report on non-endowed, current use and annual funds too? | Different funds need different financials. |
| How are student and faculty stories collected? | Surveys with text and email reminders get more responses than one email. |
| Can a story be edited once and update everywhere it appears? | One recipient often appears in several donors’ reports. |
| What happens when a fund had no recipient or nobody wrote back? | Conditional wording keeps every report accurate. |
| Who designs the templates, and can they match your brand? | Versions by college, division or donor level are common. |
| Which delivery formats are supported? | Print, emailed PDF and microsite each suit different donors. |
| How much staff time does each report take? | Time per report decides whether you can reach every donor. |
Where Awarded fits
Awarded’s Donor Reporting Studio is a dedicated reporting platform for higher education. It takes donor data from your CRM, financials from finance by fund code and recipients from your SIS or awarding system, and matches each fund to its donors, financials and recipients. Awarded’s team reviews the data files and designs your templates from your brand guidelines or an existing report, with branches by college, division or donor level.
Students and fund managers answer short surveys sent with text and email reminders, Awarded cleans up spelling and grammar, and your team approves each story. Reports go out as print-ready PDFs for your mail house, emailed PDFs from your address or microsites. Colorado State University cut staff hours on donor reporting by 94%, and Abilene Christian University spent 57% less time reviewing donor reports.
To see the report types Awarded produces, start with the donor reports guide, or compare Awarded with other approaches on the comparisons page.
Frequently asked questions
What is donor stewardship reporting software?
It is software that produces the reports donors receive about their gifts: impact reports, endowment reports, fund statements and reports on current use funds. A dedicated platform combines donor, fund, financial and recipient data, collects stories, and builds a personalized report for each donor in your institution's design.
Can we build donor reports in our CRM?
Often, yes, for letter-style reports and simple fund statements. CRMs such as Raiser's Edge or Salesforce hold donor and gift data well. Multi-page, designed reports with student stories, photos and financials from finance usually need another tool, because that data lives outside the CRM.
When does InDesign or Canva stop being practical?
When the number of personalized reports grows past what your team can build and proof by hand. Design tools give full creative control, but every report is assembled individually, so time grows with each donor and fund, and late data changes mean rework.
What should we look for in a donor reporting platform?
One report per donor across all their funds or one per fund, financial data by fund code, student and fund manager story collection with reminders, conditional wording for funds with no recipient, your own design, and delivery as print-ready PDF, email or microsite.
Do we need to replace our CRM to use a reporting platform?
No. A reporting platform works alongside your CRM. Donor and fund data come from the CRM, financials from finance and recipients from your SIS or awarding system, and the CRM stays your system of record.
Amaan Badruddin is the CEO of Awarded Software, the scholarship management and financial stewardship platform used by 100+ campuses. He founded Awarded in 2022 to change how scholarships are awarded and managed across U.S. higher education, helping financial aid and advancement teams put donor funds to work and show donors their impact. He studied at Northwestern University and is based in Brooklyn, New York.
Follow on LinkedIn
