Donor intent compliance: a fund audit checklist
A four-part checklist for auditing restricted funds against donor intent and the law: legality, feasibility, documentation and utilization, plus what to do with the findings.

A donor intent compliance audit checks every restricted fund in four ways. Is the restriction legal? Can it actually be met? Is the donor’s intent documented? Is the money being spent? Work through each fund’s gift agreement, criteria and spending against this checklist, record what you find, and fix issues with your general counsel.
Why fund audits matter now
Old agreements carry new risk. Many endowed funds were written decades ago, under different laws, for programs that may no longer exist. The award criteria were often retyped into spreadsheets several times since. A fund audit catches three kinds of problems before they become a donor complaint, a news story or a letter from a regulator:
- Restrictions that may now be illegal.
- Restrictions nobody can meet, so the money sits unawarded.
- Funds where nobody can find the original agreement, so nobody is sure what the donor intended.
Donor Relations Group (DRG) teaches a simple test for any restriction: is it legal, is it possible, and is it practical? The checklist below builds on that framing and adds two checks that come up in every audit we run: documentation and utilization.
1. Legality checklist
Start here, because a legal problem outranks everything else.
- Does the fund restrict eligibility by race, color or national origin?
- Does it restrict by sex or gender?
- Does it restrict by religion, age, disability or another protected characteristic?
- Does it use a proxy for a protected class, such as membership in a group defined by race, or a “heritage” requirement?
- Does the donor, a family member or a donor-appointed committee choose or approve the recipient?
- Is the fund earmarked for a specific, named person?
- Could the donor, a relative or a business the donor controls benefit from the fund, such as a family member being eligible or selected?
- Is the class of eligible students broad enough to count as a charitable class?
- Is each criterion written as a requirement or a preference, and does that match the donor’s intent? (See requirements vs preferences.)
General legal background
These are the rules most often behind a legality flag:
- Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 bars discrimination based on race, color or national origin in programs that receive federal financial assistance. Scholarships at institutions that take federal funds fall within its scope.
- Title IX of the Education Amendments of 1972 bars sex discrimination in federally funded education programs. Federal regulations allow some sex-restricted scholarships under specific conditions, so this area needs counsel’s reading.
- Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard (2023) ended race-conscious admissions. Many general counsels now apply its reasoning to scholarships, though institutions take different positions.
- IRS rules for charitable gifts generally require the institution to control recipient selection. A gift earmarked for a particular individual, or one where the donor picks the winner, risks losing its status as a deductible charitable gift. Donors can help shape the criteria, but final selection belongs to the institution. These rules also restrict gifts that benefit the donor or the donor’s family, often discussed as self-dealing or private benefit.
Rules vary by state and institution type. Faith-based and single-sex institutions often have different exemptions. Your counsel’s posture decides what gets flagged.
This is general information, not legal advice; check with your general counsel.
2. Feasibility checklist
Feasibility asks whether the fund can actually be awarded as written. This is DRG’s “possible” and “practical” in one step.
- Does the program, major or department named in the agreement still exist?
- How many current students meet all the requirements together? Count the students who meet every criterion at once. “Junior, ocean engineering, from one county, GPA of 3.9 or higher” may leave one student or none.
- Are there vague terms like “deserving” or “of good moral character” that nobody can measure?
- Does the fund depend on information you don’t collect, such as hometown or career plans?
- Are preferences being treated as hard requirements?
- Does the agreement include a flexibility or variance clause for when the purpose can no longer be met?
Stacked preferences are the most common cause of unawardable funds. Each one sounds reasonable. Together they shrink the pool to nothing.
3. Documentation checklist
You can’t prove compliance with intent you can’t find.
- Is there a signed gift agreement, MOU or fund establishment document for the fund?
- If there are amendments, is it clear which document governs?
- Do the criteria in your awarding system or spreadsheet match the agreement word for word in meaning?
- Are naming, reporting and stewardship commitments recorded, and is anyone tracking them?
- For funds with no documentation at all, have you written a memo to file that records what is known: the fund’s history, how it has been used, and the rationale for current criteria?
- Is the governing document stored where awarding, finance and donor relations can all see it?
Funds with no paper trail are common. A memo to file signed off by the right people is far better than nothing, and it gives future staff something to work from.
4. Utilization checklist
A fund that complies with every restriction but never spends still fails the donor.
- What percentage of this year’s spendable amount was awarded or spent? (Use the payout for endowed funds and the spending target for current use funds.)
- Has the fund gone two or more years without an award?
- Is accumulated surplus growing year over year?
- If the fund is behind, is the cause a restriction (see feasibility) or a process problem, such as nobody reviewing it?
- Is a fund manager responsible for it, with a deadline?
How to find and spend unspent restricted funds covers spending targets and spend-down plans in detail.
Rate and route every finding
Give each finding a rating so the team knows what to handle first:
| Rating | Meaning | Typical owner |
|---|---|---|
| Red | Likely legal problem, or a fund that cannot be awarded | General counsel with donor relations |
| Yellow | Vague, overly narrow, or poorly documented | Donor relations with financial aid |
| Green | No issues found | No action; re-screen on schedule |
For each red or yellow finding, record the clause, the reason it was flagged, a suggested revision that keeps the donor’s purpose, and the decision made. Document the rationale for every override. If counsel decides a flagged restriction is acceptable, write down why.
Fix what you find
The fix depends on the problem. Common paths:
- Interpret within intent. If the agreement allows discretion, administer the fund in a way that honors the purpose without the problem language. Record the reasoning.
- Contact the donor or family. Many donors agree to revised language once they understand the issue.
- Amend the agreement. Replace the problem clause with language that keeps the donor’s purpose, such as financial need in place of a protected-class criterion.
- Use a variance or flexibility clause if the agreement includes one.
- Seek court approval to modify the restriction when the donor can’t be reached and no clause applies. Your counsel will advise on the process in your state.
Then re-screen the fund and keep the audit trail. When legal guidance changes, re-run the audit across the portfolio instead of rereading every agreement by hand.
Prevent the next problem at signing
Most audit findings start in the gift agreement. Screening new agreements before the donor signs is cheaper than fixing them later. What an endowed scholarship gift agreement should include lists the clauses that keep a fund awardable.
How Awarded helps
Fund Audits screens your whole portfolio of gift agreements, MOUs and amendments for legality, feasibility and utilization. Each finding shows the clause highlighted in the original document, a red, yellow or green rating, the reason, and suggested replacement language. Your counsel sets the rules once, and the portfolio is re-screened when they change. Findings are for counsel’s review and aren’t legal advice. For new agreements, GATO runs the same checks before a draft reaches the donor.
Frequently asked questions
How often should we audit restricted funds?
Run a full audit once, then re-screen whenever legal guidance or your counsel’s posture changes, and at least every few years. Screen every new gift agreement before signing.
Who should be involved in a fund audit?
Donor relations or gift administration usually leads. General counsel decides legal questions, financial aid checks feasibility against real students, and finance supplies spending data.
What is the difference between a preference and a restriction?
A requirement (or restriction) must be met for a student to receive the award. A preference only decides who goes first among eligible students. Treating preferences as requirements is a common reason funds go unspent.
Can a donor choose the scholarship recipient?
Generally no. Institutions typically keep final selection to protect the gift’s charitable status, though donors can help shape the criteria. This is general information, not legal advice; check with your general counsel.
Amaan Badruddin is the CEO of Awarded Software, the scholarship management and financial stewardship platform used by 100+ campuses. He founded Awarded in 2022 to change how scholarships are awarded and managed across U.S. higher education, helping financial aid and advancement teams put donor funds to work and show donors their impact. He studied at Northwestern University and is based in Brooklyn, New York.
Follow on LinkedIn
