WEBINARNovember 19th: Streamlining your gift agreements, with the Donor Relations Group. Register now →
Donor Reporting

What to put in a donor report when a fund wasn't awarded or no student wrote back

Every reporting cycle has funds with no recipient and recipients with no story. Here is what to put in those donor reports, with sample wording, so every donor still gets an honest, complete report.

ABAmaan BadruddinCEO, Awarded Software·6 min readin
A tidy desk with a desktop computer, laptop and tablet, ready for a donor reporting review

When a fund wasn’t awarded, tell the donor plainly why, what the balance is and what happens next. When students didn’t write back, list the students the fund supported, with whatever details your policy allows, and feature any stories you do have. Either way, the donor should still get an accurate report on time.

These are the reports most teams dread. A fund with no recipient looks like a failure, and a fund whose five students all ignored the survey leaves a hole where the stories should be. The tempting response is to skip those donors this year. That is usually the worst option: silence reads as neglect, and the donor’s gift officer is left without an answer when the donor asks.

Why these reports happen

Funds go unawarded for ordinary reasons, and naming the reason is the first step to explaining it. The most common ones:

  • Restrictive criteria. A fund limited to students from one county, in one major, with a minimum GPA, may have no eligible student in a given year.
  • No applicants. Students who qualify don’t apply, often because the fund is listed only in one department.
  • Timing. Awards were made after the reporting snapshot, or a recipient didn’t enroll full-time and the award was pulled back.
  • Spending policy. Under many endowment spending policies, a new endowed fund may not distribute anything in its first year or two.
  • The program changed. The major or program named in the gift agreement no longer exists.

Some of these are fixable this year, and some need a conversation with the donor. Our post on the utilization problem covers why so many restricted funds go underspent.

When a fund wasn’t awarded

Write a short, direct explanation. Donors respond better to candor than to vague reassurance. A good section includes four things:

  1. What happened. “This year, no student met all of the fund’s criteria” or “This new fund will make its first award in the 2027-28 academic year.”
  2. Where the money is. For an endowed fund, the spendable amount carries forward or is reinvested under your spending policy. For a current use fund, the balance is still there. Say so, with the figure.
  3. What you’re doing about it. Wider promotion, a review of the criteria with the donor, or a plan to award two students next year.
  4. A human voice. A note from the fund manager, dean or financial aid director carries more weight than boilerplate.

Sample wording:

“Thank you for your continued support of the Rivera Family Scholarship. This year, no applicant met every criterion in the fund agreement, so the scholarship was not awarded. The $4,800 available this year remains in the fund and will be available next year. Our financial aid team is working with the School of Engineering to reach more eligible students, and your gift officer will be in touch to talk about the criteria.”

Keep the fund statement in the report. The financials still matter: market value, distributions and the amount available to spend show the fund is intact and growing.

When the criteria are the problem

If a fund goes unawarded year after year, the criteria usually need attention. Your gift agreement may include a flexibility clause that allows the institution to adjust when the original purpose can’t be met. Otherwise, the conversation is with the donor or their family. Our post on requirements and preferences explains how to rewrite hard restrictions as preferences, which keeps the donor’s intent while widening the pool.

Some criteria also carry legal risk, such as restrictions based on race, sex or religion, or a donor who selects the recipient. Those funds need review by your general counsel before you report on them as usual. This is general information, not legal advice; check with your general counsel. A fund audit can screen every agreement for these issues at once, along with funds that have gone unspent for several years.

When no student wrote back

The fund did its job; you just don’t have the student’s words. Report the impact you can verify:

  • A recipient roster. First name and last initial, major, class year and hometown, in whatever combination your policy permits. Some institutions drop hometown when it could identify a student in a small town.
  • A count. “This year, your scholarship supported 6 students.” Add a cumulative figure if you track it: “Since it was established, the fund has supported 41 students.”
  • Short profiles. A sentence or two per student built from the information you already have (major, year, activities) reads better than a bare table.
  • Stories from the students who did respond. If two of six wrote back, feature those two after the roster.
  • A fund manager or faculty note when students are silent.
  • Institution-wide context. A short page on scholarship recipients overall (number of students supported, share who are first-generation) gives donors a sense of the larger picture.

Then fix the leadership message. If the president’s letter says “enjoy the stories in these pages,” it shouldn’t go to donors with no stories. Write conditional wording into the template, with one sentence for reports with student responses and another for reports without. One director told us her team did a lot of manual work one summer, downloading reports and editing them by hand, because their template had only one version of that letter.

When students declined to share

Consent comes first. If a student answered your survey but declined to have their name or story shared, archive the response so it never reaches a report. You can still count the student: “Your scholarship supported 6 students, including 4 who chose to share their stories below.” Decide your policy on names before the cycle starts, and apply it the same way across every report.

Prevent the gap next year

The best fix is upstream:

  • Ask for stories early. Send the survey link by text and email as soon as students accept their awards, with reminders. See how to get more student thank-you notes.
  • Track utilization during the year. Finance and advancement should see which funds are behind before the report is due. Our Fund Management tools show unspent and dormant funds across the portfolio.
  • Match more students to more funds. Many “no eligible student” cases come from limited data. Combining SIS data with application answers widens the pool. Southwestern Adventist University reached 100% fund utilization, and Clarkson University raised fund utilization 15% year over year.
  • Plan the wording in advance. Write your no-recipient and no-response language once, get it approved and reuse it.

How Awarded handles these reports

Awarded’s Donor Reporting Studio builds conditional wording into each template: a report can explain why a fund wasn’t awarded, include a note from the fund manager, switch to a recipient roster when only a few students responded, or change the leadership message when there are no stories. Student surveys go out with text and email reminders, and your team approves every response before it reaches a donor. Every donor still gets an accurate report, delivered as a print-ready PDF for your mail house, an emailed PDF or a microsite. For more on report structure, see our guides to annual impact reports and current use fund reports.

Frequently asked questions

Should we skip the report if a fund wasn’t awarded?

No. Send the report with a short explanation, the fund’s financials and your plan for next year. Skipping it leaves the donor and their gift officer without an answer.

What can we share about students who didn’t respond?

Whatever your policy allows: often first name and last initial, major and class year. Many institutions leave out hometown when it could identify a student.

How do we word a report when no student wrote back?

Thank the donor, say how many students the fund supported, include a roster or short profiles and feature any stories you have. Make sure the leadership letter doesn’t promise stories that aren’t there.

What if the same fund goes unawarded every year?

Review the criteria. Check the gift agreement for a flexibility clause, talk with the donor or family about rewriting hard requirements as preferences, and ask counsel to review any criteria that may carry legal risk.

AB
Amaan BadruddinCEO, Awarded Software

Amaan Badruddin is the CEO of Awarded Software, the scholarship management and financial stewardship platform used by 100+ campuses. He founded Awarded in 2022 to change how scholarships are awarded and managed across U.S. higher education, helping financial aid and advancement teams put donor funds to work and show donors their impact. He studied at Northwestern University and is based in Brooklyn, New York.

Follow on LinkedIn

Transform your scholarship awarding & stewardship.

Attract and retain more students and donors, starting this awarding cycle.

Try Awarded

Try the platform yourself

Tell us where to reach you and we'll set you up to explore Awarded with sample funds, students and donor reports.

Products you'd like to try (optional)

We'll only use your details to set up access and follow up. See our privacy policy.